Dragon Quest Builders (Switch) Review

Minecraft: The JRPG

I admit I’m not a hardcore Minecraft fan. I enjoy playing that 3D pixel block-crafting series but am not the kind of person who spends hours creating exquisite masterpieces. However, as a fan of RPGs, I was drawn to Dragon Quest Builders, Square Enix’s take on the sandbox craft genre and a spinoff of the long-running Dragon Quest series. As a goal-oriented person, I resonated with the game’s mission structure, role-playing elements, and overarching plot.

Here’s the Video Version for your viewing pleasure!


Unlike Minecraft, Dragon Quest Builders sets up an intriguing story. Your character wakes up in a parallel world of the first Dragon Quest (Dragon Warrior in the West), where that game’s hero joined up with the final boss instead of defeating it. As a result, the world of Alefgard fell into ruin and the remaining survivors lost the ability to rebuild. That is, except for your character, who miraculously retains the power to create and now stands as Alefgard’s last hope. The setup is compelling, and the throwbacks will please fans of the series. The world map is based on the first NES game’s layout, and you are essentially rebuilding the same towns that once stood there.

DragonQuestBuilders_Switch_Review1.jpg.jpg
Heigh Ho. Heigh Ho. It’s off to work we go.

The building process is straightforward. Making structures involves gathering blocks of earth around you and placing them back down however you like. To create the items that fill the rooms, you go to a designated workstation and choose what to make from a list, including decorative furniture and practical healing items. If you have enough of the required materials, you can craft the desired item. It’s a streamlined process that is fun to master. Rebuilding the town is also a guided experience, and you primarily do so by heeding your residents’ requests. Occasionally, you’ll have to follow a blueprint and build an entire structure exactly as it is on the design.

DragonQuestBuilders_Switch_Review2.jpg.jpg
That’s it! I’ve come up with a new recipe!

Indeed, the game holds your hand more so than a truly open game like Minecraft, and the experience may bore those who just want to jump right in. Conversely, for those like me who feel that those large sandbox games can get overwhelming, Dragon Quest Builders’ structured pacing is superb. I was always eager to craft the next item or build the next room, and the blueprints made great templates. In fact, the game’s guidance inspired me to improvise on the recommended designs to make the town my own. Aside from the blueprints, I didn’t feel creatively limited, and as long as I fulfilled requests, I advanced the story. Additionally, as I built, I helped repopulate the town, which was just as fun. In the same vein as the Animal Crossing series, the game makes you feel like you are both the creator and mayor of a steadily evolving town. As such, this game ends up feeling like a sim just as much as it does a sandbox builder.

Nonetheless, crafting is just one half of the game. The other half sets you forth into the ravaged land to gather materials. Resource gathering is an adventure in itself. Scavenging the blocky, destructible world is fun, even though the individual areas aren’t that huge. You have limited inventory space, but luckily, you eventually get a magical chest that items can automatically teleport into. As you get better materials, you learn new recipes. This includes stronger weapons, which let you break previously indestructible blocks, allowing you to craft better items. It’s an addictive progression loop that encourages the grind.

DragonQuestBuilders_Switch_Review3.jpg.jpg
Destroy the world…to get building materials – alternative recycling.

All that equipment is useful for combat, too. Roaming about are dangerous enemies, all of which will be familiar to Dragon Quest veterans. Instead of the series’ turn-based battles, Dragon Quest Builders approaches a real-time action RPG approach similar to The Legend of Zelda or Secret of Mana. It’s pretty simple, and hacking repeatedly at most enemies is as effective a strategy as any other. There were some occasions when my attack missed even though I was close to an enemy. But thanks to jump attacks and charge moves, I found my character agile and capable of fighting any enemy, even large bosses that required special strategies to defeat. My only peeve was how foes could destroy the buildings I worked so hard to make. This is even more discouraging while fighting on your home turf against bosses, who can annihilate your creations with one fell swoop.

DragonQuestBuilders_Switch_Review4.jpg.jpg
All your favorites from Dragon Quest are here, like this scorpion.

This leads to my biggest disappointment: the segmented chapter structure. There are four chapters in the game, but after each one, you leave everything behind to move on to the next – your town, the people, and even your stats all disappear as you resurrect anew in another world. While you can at least go back and keep playing that chapter ad infinitum, the fact that nothing carries over is demotivating. It makes sense to restart supplies for a new scenario, but losing your character progress and previous town makes chapters feel too disjointed. I did like how your main goals changed with each chapter, for instance, shifting from merely rebuilding to creating infirmaries to heal poisoned survivors in Chapter 2. Nevertheless, I would have liked a more connected playthrough that incorporated elements from previous chapters in subsequent ones.

Each chapter takes about seven to ten hours, depending on how you pace your adventure and if you attempt the chapter-specific challenges. Upon finishing Chapter 1, you unlock a free building mode called Terra Incognita that lets you build whatever you want, which may appeal to players seeking more open gameplay. Alas, it’s not as engaging as it sounds. The positives are that you can build from your repertoire of recipes, and enemies won’t destroy your structures. Unfortunately, you can only share creations built within a specific patch of land that is slightly smaller than the typical town size. You can still make stellar creations within that limitation, and I was usually impressed after downloading others’ masterpieces. But that’s it: no visiting or interacting with others. There’s a missed potential without a robust multiplayer mode. A highlight is the new Sabrecub mount exclusive to the Nintendo Switch version. Aside from being an adorable, fast ride, the Sabrecub lets you obtain pixels, a material that can be used to fashion 8-bit structures, a fun nod to nostalgic fans.

DragonQuestBuilders_Switch_Review6.jpg
Welcome to my 8-bit Pandaville!

Otherwise, there isn’t anything unique about the Switch version, besides the obvious portability, which fits perfectly with the sandbox nature of the game. Touch screen support would have been perfect for inventory management, but it’s sadly absent. The game performs well both docked and undocked, running at a smooth frame rate. The 720p resolution doesn’t look as nice as on other platforms, but the world and characters remain charming thanks to the colorful, blocky artstyle. The soundtrack consists of remastered songs from the original Dragon Quest, which is to say, old-school medieval music that is as catchy and grand as ever, albeit repetitive after a while.

DragonQuestBuilders_Switch_Review5.jpg.jpg
Good night Builder. Good night town.

Conclusion

Dragon Quest Builders is an engaging sandbox craft game that appeals to players who desire a more structured Minecraft campaign. It’s satisfying to build entire towns, and the RPG elements and addictive feedback loop may keep some playing for hours on end. Although I was disappointed with the segmented chapters and limited free build mode, I still had plenty of fun with the core campaign. The Switch version may not be the ideal version for everyone, but it’s still an excellent option, especially for newcomers. My only wish is that Square Enix can craft an even better experience with Dragon Quest Builders 2.

Score: 8/10

Note: A review copy was used for this article. This review was originally written for DarkStation in March 2018.

What do you think of Dragon Quest Builders? Are you a fan of Minecraft or any other games in the sandbox builder genre? Which ones are your favorite? What’s your favorite game in the Dragon Quest series? Please share any thoughts or questions in the comments below! Thank you so much for reading and watching!

 

Advertisements

20 thoughts on “Dragon Quest Builders (Switch) Review

  1. What a lovely review you’ve cooked up! My favorite part was your Ignis impression in your video! ;D This looks like a fun game for creative types–or creative types seeking some guidance. Sort of like a more guided Labo even! I don’t like the concept of losing all your progress between chapters, though. Shouldn’t they “build” off each other? What I do like is the cross-over between Dragon Quest and Minecraft. I haven’t played much of Dragon Quest, but as a huge fan of JRPGs like Final Fantasy, I’d like to try it out someday. Also, I’d love to have a Final Fantasy Minecraft. But wait! One does exist! And for XV too!! That’s it! I’ve come up with a new recipeh!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much as always! I had a feeling you’d like my Ignis impression. 😉 It’s definitely like a guided Labo. With Labo so much in the limelight, I was excited to go back to building in a digital way. I would definitely love Final Fantasy Minecraft, with a similar style to Dragon Quest Builders but using FF assets – maybe the ones from World of Final Fantasy. Yeah, there’s Final Fantasy XV Minecraft now, but that’s not the same as a game “built” from scratch. ;)

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Hahaha yes! I’ve always wanted Dragon Quest amiibo period, be it Sabrecub, Slime, or the hero Erdrick! And Final Fantasy amiibo for that matter. Just Cloud is not enough. 😛 So I’m hoping that more Dragon Quest representation gets in the next Super Smash Bros. so we get their amiibo haha.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Great review! I loved the game (played on PS4, still have to finish it…) and can’t wait for the sequel because with the promised addtions it can be even better. I understand the negative points like chapter structure for example, but it wasn’t as bad as I expected and added some challenge. The first moments in each chapter were hard because of the limited resources.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you very much!! I actually first played it on PS4, but didn’t finish it on there. Figures it would take the Switch version to get me to keep playing hahaha. The self-contained structure enhanced the survival elements, especially during each chapter’s early parts. I just wish the world felt more connected, and that there was more of a reason to progress your character’s health stat for future chapters.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Nice! This looks like a fun hybrid of sandbox building and life action RPGs, albeit a somewhat over regulated one. It’s a shame there isn’t a multiplayer option, this seems built for it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you as always for your wonderful words my good man! I like that term, life action RPGs. It reminds me of Fantasy Life for 3DS, which was a fusion of action RPG and life sim. It’s similar to this but with less freeform building and more RPG elements. Also, the sequel will thankfully have a more substantial multiplayer mode, so I look forward to seeing how it turns out!

      Like

  4. I downloaded the demo a few months ago. I think if I’d been more into Minecraft I would’ve loved it! That’s really cool the game is essentially a “what if” of that question. I remember how the Dragonlord asked that at the end and if you say yes, it’s game over. It reminds me of how Legend of Zelda branches off and has “Link is dead” timeline! Great review as always 😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you very much as always! 😀 I liked Dragon Quest Builders more than Minecraft, but not more than the Dragon Quest RPGs. The “what if” idea is wonderfully executed, and I’m so surprised Square Enix went in such a clever direction. Funny enough, the “Link is dead” comment reminded me of how in the first Dragon Warrior game, it actually said “Link is dead” on one of the gravestones as a jab at the series hahaha!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s